Chamber and committees

The Scottish Executive has discretion under the Code of Practice on Access to Scottish Executive Information not to release information which would harm the frankness and candour of discussion and advice or where any information was given in confidence.

No. It would not be appropriate for the Scottish Executive to disclose information which would harm the frankness and candour of discussion and advice given in confidence including between the Executive and the Scottish Transport Group and the Trustees of the Scottish Transport Group pension schemes. The provisions of Part II of the Code of Practice on Access are relevant.

As I announced in the Parliament on 29 November, Scottish ministers have secured for distribution, to former members of the Scottish Transport Group pension schemes, an additional £18 million by agreement with Treasury Ministers. This means that up to £118 million will now be distributed to beneficiaries. I have no plans to discuss this further with Treasury Ministers.

The content of the application forms is a matter for the universities themselves and the Universities and Colleges Admissions Service (UCAS), the body through which all applications for university places are routed. The UCAS application form includes a question on occupational background which the guidance to applicants explains is used by UCAS for the purpose of monitoring equal opportunities. The information is used by UCAS in anonymised form for statistical purposes, such as the compilation of comparative data on application and entry rates from specific social groups. UCAS advises applicants that the information is not passed to institutions until after the selection process is complete.

The administration of the Scottish Transport Group (STG) pension schemes and the securing of benefits under the schemes are entirely matters for the trustees of the scheme. On wind-up of the STG pension schemes, and the dissolution of the Scottish Transport Group, any sum remaining in the group will fall to the UK Exchequer. Scottish ministers have, however, secured the distribution of up to £118 million by way of ex-gratia payments to former members of the STG Pension Schemes.

The conclusions reached by the Rural Development Committee recorded in these paragraphs in the Stage 1 Report relate to the use of terriers underground and the activities of the Scottish Hill Packs. The Executive neither propose to implement a policy nor introduce measures to give effect to those conclusions. The Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill has undergone amendment at Stage 2 to cater for pest control exceptions, reflecting the views of the committee. That legislation, as determined at Stage 3 and ultimately interpreted by the courts, will determine what use of dogs is permitted and what constitutes an offence.

I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-20727.

Yes. We are considering the Bill as amended at Stage 2 and confirm that we will bring forward any Executive amendments as soon as we can.

The Executive remain neutral in relation to the policy of this Bill except where it cuts across Executive policy, has a financial implication for the Executive or is deemed to be unworkable in law. On consideration of the Bill, as amended at Stage 2, I can confirm that any amendments that the Executive consider are required at Stage 3 will be technical in nature.

BEAR's contract is complex and detailed and minor breaches will inevitably occur. However, there are set procedures for rectification of more serious failures. The first step of this procedure is to issue a default notice to BEAR to ensure the level of service is maintained.