Holyrood’s Finance Committee publishes views heard at Ayrshire visit on priorities for the Scottish Budget

19 September 2023

The views of people in Ayrshire, on what the Scottish Government’s budget priorities should be, have been published today by a Holyrood committee.

The move follows MSPs from the Scottish Parliament’s Finance and Public Administration Committee visiting Largs last month (30 August) to hear about Scotland’s budget challenges, drawing on the experiences of businesses, public bodies, community groups and those who live and work there.

The visit was part of a parliamentary inquiry into the sustainability of Scotland’s finances.

It follows the Scottish Government’s forecast that public spending in Scotland is set to outstrip expected income by £1 billion in 2024/25. The forecast means the government will not have sufficient money to fund all the spending it currently wishes to make.

Read a detailed summary note of the wide-ranging views and opinions from around 30 participants (178KB, pdf) posted 18 September 2023

Finance and Public Administration Committee Convener Kenneth Gibson MSP said:

“The Committee was keen to hear from people directly about their priorities for spending and taxation and for addressing the financial and demographic challenges ahead.

“The people of Largs – including businesses, third sector bodies and residents – gave us robust views on a whole range of tax and spending issues, including on what the Scottish Government’s fiscal priorities should be next year and beyond.

“All the views we heard will help inform the committee’s scrutiny of the government’s budget in the autumn. I’d like to thank everybody who took the time to meet with us in Largs at the Vikingar! centre."

Cross-party MSPs from the Holyrood committee led discussions in five separate groups with attendees representing the business community, public bodies, local authorities, local health organisations, community groups and the third sector.

Extracts from the discussions include:

Discussion with businesses, led by Liz Smith MSP

Some concerns were raised regarding the lack of mention of businesses within the Scottish Government’s current priorities. It was felt that priority should be placed on outcomes rather than on inputs. For example, health and wellbeing is an outcome which results from creating wealth, and that priority should therefore be given to creating the wealth.
Discussion with public bodies, local authorities, and local health organisations, led by Kenneth Gibson MSP and Ross Greer MSP

Views expressed including the need to prioritise funding to address the twin crises of the cost of living and the climate. It was felt that aa shift towards more investment from the private sector is needed to plug the ‘green funding gap’, along with prioritising investment in infrastructure to help achieve a net zero economy.
Discussions with the third sector and local community groups, led by Michelle Thomson MSP

Much of the group discussion focussed on the NHS and healthcare spend. Issues raised included over-50s needing to opt for private healthcare as they are not receiving the treatment they require through the NHS due to the length of waiting lists.
Discussion with community groups and the third sector, led by John Mason MSP

Discussions included where greater funding for the Scottish Budget could be achieved as well as on where there should be greater expenditure. Priorities discussed included tackling tax evasion both at an individual and business level, considering means testing of currently universal benefits seeking greater income revenue from land taxes.
Discussion with community groups and the third sector, led by Michael Marra MSP

There was strong opposition to raising taxes to support services within the group, with some arguing that “people are struggling as it is”. It was noted that council tax rates are particularly high in Largs, which is widely seen as a well-off area, despite considerable poverty - a perception that leads to local organisations missing out on funding opportunities.

Ayrshire participants

Around 30 representatives from the following organisations took part in the event

Ayrshire Chamber of Commerce
Ayrshire Community Trust
Blue Diamond
Cameron Centre
East Ayrshire Council
Grasshopper Toys
Largs Thistle
NatureScot
NHS Ayrshire and Arran
North Ayrshire Council
Opening The Shutters
Skelmorlie Secret Bunker
South of Scotland Enterprise
Supply Chain Management Group
West Kilbride Community Association
Wilkies
Yes Your Entire Self

Media interviews

Convener Kenneth Gibson MSP is available for interview.

Contact Eric MacLeod below.

Media information

Eric MacLeod

Text Relay calls welcome

0771 471 3332

[email protected]

Committee information

Joanne McNaughton

Text Relay calls welcome

[email protected]

Public information

Telephone enquiry line: 0800 092 7500 or 0131 348 5395 (Gàidhlig)
[email protected]
Text 07786 209 888
We also welcome calls using the Text Relay service or in British Sign

Language through contactSCOTLAND-BSL.

You can also follow us on twitter @scotparl

Like us on Facebook for updates on news and events

Or find out more on YouTube