Chamber and committees

I had to leave the room briefly, so I apologise if you have already covered this. We spoke earlier about an ecosystems approach to fisheries. What would that look like? I believe that it would involve balancing the sustainability of cod stocks with the economic viability of the fishing industry. Can you cite some examples of how that approach has worked in the rest of the world?

Good morning. We have heard evidence that the cod box is destined to fail, and it is questionable whether the Scottish Government’s actions will be able to recover cod stocks. Does the current cod closure provide adequate protection for spawning cod in the Clyde?

I will start with David Nairn.

Thank you. I ask Calum Duncan the same question.

To develop Alasdair Allan’s questions, what is your assessment of the evidence, the reasoning, the process and the science that underpinned the prohibition proposals that led to the Scottish Government’s removal of the exemptions on the Clyde? It would be fantastic if you could give examples to develop that. I will start with Bally Philp.

I ask Elaine Whyte the same question. Do you want me to repeat it?

Do you think that the Scottish Government’s decisions have disproportionately impacted on one fishing method over another without the clear scientific evidence that you discuss?

Cabinet secretary, can I push you on the financial aspect of delivering fairly and equitably to all local authorities so that the ambition of the policy statement is met and everybody has access to good food? Is it in the Scottish Government’s interest to look at the financial implications of funding more generously areas that do not have access to short supply chains so that everybody, from people in city centres to those in island communities, can benefit from the intention of the Good Food Nation (Scotland) Bill?

What would happen then? Would local authorities have the confidence—

Do not worry, convener. I can leave it.

In a previous meeting, George Burgess said that there is no need for a new, bespoke oversight board, but the Scottish National Party manifesto said:

“As part of a Good Food Nation Bill, we will create a single independent Scottish Food agency”.

What is your opinion on that?